Financial advisers spend a lot of time talking about risk, whether that’s market risk, inflation, longevity, tax, sequence of returns, concentration, long-term care … The list seems endless.
But clients don’t necessarily experience retirement risk as a category on a planning report. They experience it as a knot in the stomach:
- What if I run out of money?
- What if I become a burden to my children?
- What if I retire and lose my identity?
- What if my spouse dies first?
- What if the market falls right after I stop working?
- What if I need care and there is no good place for me to go?
For financial advisers, these fears can be frustrating if they appear to contradict the numbers. The plan may be strong. The portfolio may be diversified. The Monte Carlo analysis may look solid. The client may have more than enough. And yet the fear is real.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more – straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice – straight to your e-mail.
That is where the adviser’s work becomes more human. The best advisers don’t simply tell clients not to worry. They help clients understand which worries are emotional noise and which ones are pointing to real planning gaps.
That is the difference between fear that paralyzes and fear that prepares.
Start by normalizing the fear
Billy Spencer, a wealth manager at Crestwood Advisors in Boston, says fear can be viewed as a feedback mechanism. “The question is not whether a client feels fear. The question is whether the fear is controllable and actionable,” says Spencer.
That framing can be powerful.
Clients approaching retirement are often stepping into unfamiliar territory. For 30 or 40 years, the work rhythm was clear: Earn, save, invest, repeat.
Retirement changes the assignment. Now clients must spend from assets, make healthcare decisions, think about housing, prepare for aging and build a life that may no longer revolve around professional achievement.
For high-performing executives and business owners, that can be especially unsettling.
Jeff Blomberg, managing partner and co-founder at Mountain Legacy Family Wealth Partners in Colorado, works with many executives who have accumulated substantial wealth. In his experience, the issue is not always whether they can afford to retire. It’s what retirement will ask of them emotionally.
- What will I do with my time?
- How will I stay challenged?
- How will my relationships change?
- How do I remain useful?
Those are not soft questions. They are central retirement questions. Advisers who ignore them may miss the real source of client anxiety.
Separate emotional fear from planning risk
A client’s fear of running out of money may mean several different things. It may mean the client truly has not saved enough, or the withdrawal rate is too high. It may mean the portfolio is poorly positioned, or the client has not planned for long-term care.
Or it may mean the client grew up in a household where money was scarce and cannot emotionally trust abundance, even when the plan is sound. The adviser’s job is to help tell the difference.
Bob Dietz, a wealth strategist at AllianceBernstein, works with high-net-worth and ultra-high-net-worth clients on issues such as tax planning, portfolio stress-testing, wealth transfer and retirement income. “Healthy fear often points to a planning gap. If the fear causes the client to focus, engage and take action, it can be constructive,” he says.
That may mean stress-testing the plan under poor capital market assumptions, and modeling life expectancy, taxes, inflation and spending. It may mean looking at the impact of Roth conversions, charitable strategies, required minimum distributions or concentrated wealth created through a business sale.
For wealthy clients, the fear may not be, “Will I be poor?” It may be, “What am I missing?”
Use the plan as a compass, not a verdict
Monte Carlo analysis to stress-test a portfolio can be useful, but should not be presented as a magic bullet. Clients may not fully understand probabilities, and even an 85% or 90% success rate can leave them wondering about the other 10% or 15%.
Spencer describes planning as a compass. It helps clients make adjustments as life unfolds. That is a healthier message than presenting a plan as something carved in stone.
Retirement may last 25 or 30 years. Markets, tax laws and clients’ health, family needs and goals will all change.
A good adviser can help clients expect that change instead of fear it. That may include regular reviews, updated projections and plain-English conversations about trade-offs.
Can the client spend more? Give more? Retire sooner? Work part time? Buy the second home? Help a child with a house down payment? Pay for grandchildren’s college? Move into a life care community?
The point is not to eliminate uncertainty. It is to make uncertainty more manageable.
Build liquidity clients can believe in
One of the simplest ways to reduce retirement fear is to give clients a clear answer to this question: Where does my spending money come from if markets fall?
Jason Dall’Acqua, CFP®, founder of Crest Wealth Advisors in Maryland, uses planning tools, stress tests and reserve strategies to help clients understand how they can fund several years of spending without being forced to sell long-term assets in a downturn.
Blomberg describes a bucket strategy that may set aside three to five years of essential expenses in safer assets while allowing the rest of the portfolio to remain invested for longer-term growth.
That kind of structure can help clients stay disciplined. It also gives advisers language they can use during volatility: We planned for this. This is why the reserve exists. This is why the portfolio is not built around one market environment.
That does not remove fear. But it can keep fear from turning into panic.
Address the fear of spending
Many retirees need help not only with saving and investing, but with spending.
This can be especially true for clients who built wealth through discipline, frugality and restraint. The habits that helped them accumulate assets may make it difficult to enjoy those assets.
Dall’Acqua says helping clients feel comfortable spending, gifting or giving to charity can be one of the most rewarding parts of the job. But it often requires more than showing a projection. It requires conversations about values:
- What is the money for?
- What experiences matter while the client is healthy?
- What would be more meaningful — leaving a larger estate later or helping children and grandchildren now?
- What charitable causes reflect the family’s values?
A healthy fear of running out of money may lead to better withdrawal planning. But an unhealthy fear may cause clients to lead a less-than-fulfilling retirement. Advisers can help clients find the middle ground.
Bring family and legacy fears into the open
Many retirement fears are really family fears:
- Will my children handle inherited wealth responsibly?
- Will one child feel treated unfairly?
- Should I help my grandchildren now?
- How do I talk about money without creating entitlement?
- Who will make decisions if I cannot?
- Will my spouse be prepared if I die first?
These concerns can lead to better planning if advisers know how to guide the conversation.
Blomberg encourages clients to think about supporting family during life, not only through inheritance. That might include education funding, help with housing, charitable giving through a donor-advised fund, or family conversations where younger generations have a voice, even if they don’t have a vote.
“Advisers don’t need to become a family therapist, but we can create the structure for better conversations,” says Blomberg.
Don’t ignore health, housing and cognitive decline
Some of the hardest retirement fears involve health.
Clients may have watched parents struggle with care decisions. They may fear dementia or becoming a burden to adult children. They may assume they can age in place, even if their home, location or family situation makes that difficult.
Spencer says these conversations often work best in smaller pieces:
- Who would you want involved if your health changed?
- Are your health care proxy and power of attorney documents current?
- What would quality care look like?
- What housing options would you consider?
- What would aging in place require?
For some clients, the answer may involve self-insuring. For others, insurance, home equity, a second-home sale or a continuing care community may be part of the plan.
The details matter less than the willingness to have the conversation before a crisis.
The adviser’s soft skills are now planning skills
The future of financial advice is not just better software, better tax analysis or better portfolios. It is also better listening.
Clients need advisers who can validate concerns without amplifying panic. They need advisers who can say, “That is a reasonable fear. Let’s see what it means in your plan.”
That takes behavioral knowledge, empathy and patience. It takes the ability to translate complex planning into decisions clients can live with.
Fear will always be part of retirement. The question is whether advisers can help clients use it well.
Healthy fear should lead to action: A stronger plan, a clearer estate strategy, a better cash reserve, a more honest family conversation, a smarter tax strategy, a more realistic housing decision or a more intentional life.
Clients do not need to be fearless. They need to be prepared.
Related Content
TOPICS
